Claiming individual liberties through an excellent constitutional courtroom: New exemplory instance of gays in the Costa Rica

Bruce Yards. Wilson, Saying individual rights as a result of an excellent constitutional legal: Brand new exemplory instance of gays inside Costa Rica, Around the globe Log of Constitutional Laws, Frequency 5, Topic dos, , Pages 242–257,


Within the 1989, a newly composed Constitutional Legal (Sala IV) immediately turned into an incredibly effective legal, finish over 160 numerous years of Costa Rican judicial inactivity. New magistrates’ measures breathed new way life into Constitution, ended official deference so you can decided authorities, and consequently transformed Costa Rican governmental lifetime. On the other hand, the latest Sala IV magistrates thought brand new part out-of guardians regarding constitutional liberties, giving rise to what is usually called a legal rights trend. The article sheds light on sudden advantages of forty-year-old Constitutional document owing to a study of the new organization statutes and you will tips under that your the fresh Courtroom works, plus it explores the brand new accomplishments and disappointments of one of your own nation’s most marginalized teams inside the seeking to protection of the constitutional rights about Courtroom.


When you look at the 1999, Costa Ricans popular its Constitution’s fiftieth anniversary. step 1 New value of one’s Composition throughout these 50 ages is continuously divided in to a few distinctive line of symptoms, pre and post brand new 1989 production of a constitutional chamber out-of the newest Supreme Courtroom (Sala Constitucional otherwise Sala IV). dos In advance of 1989, this new constitutionality away from lawmakers’ tips is scarcely confronted, and you will politicians noticed its “capability to legislate try natural,” permitting them to consistently disregard constitutional restrictions on the powers. step three Yet not, the brand new detailed personal and you may public legal rights provisions of Constitution was basically rarely managed from the Supreme Court. cuatro Those things away from Sala IV magistrates features breathed new lease of life into the Structure and you may turned Costa Rican politics, 5 as Sala IV enjoys consistently read and you may favorably felt like personal rights states. It’s widely concurred you to, given that 1989, Costa Rica has already established a judicial revolution- a great deal more specifically, good “rights” revolution-that recommended some one and you will teams out of virtually every sector from people to make towards the Court getting redress. 6

Because the magistrates of one’s Finest Legal in earlier times deferred on common branches from authorities, they now behave as energetic guardians of one’s Constitution. As a whole Sala IV magistrate, Eduardo Sancho, put it: “It is necessary understand the new Sala IV a lot less a keen establishment intended to feel in the service of one’s administrator branch, however, a bit the opposite: to protect new legal rights men and women.” 7 The magistrates possess frequently and you may decisively governed in cases of individual legal rights claims, frequently and only politically weakened and you will socially ines Sala IV decisions towards the circumstances filed by some of the most weakly organized, politically and you may socially marginalized members of Costa Rican neighborhood. In advance of performing this, it talks about the judicial organization build pre and post this new manufacturing out of Sala IV to explain the latest roots of the Court’s increased judicial activism and you may, in particular, the fresh revived value believed of the constitutional arrangements while the the latest chamber was at procedure.

step 1. From official inactivity in order to judicial activism

On the earliest 160 several years of independence, Costa Rica’s Best Court behaved like many most other Latin-american courts, running on the belief that the procedures of one’s preferred branches out-of government was constitutional except if these were egregiously and you will of course if you don’t. 8 Like in remainder of the area, Costa Rica’s constitutions incorporated debts of liberties that have been mainly ignored and you can, more often, just “parchment barriers, ineffective up against governmental power.” nine For many years there was considerable argument one of several branches from regulators concerning the judicial opinion. It was not up to 1938 that Supreme Courtroom founded their “official supremacy when you look at the constitutional issues.” ten However,, as with much of the rest of Latin The usa, new constitutional pledges from personal liberties afforded absolutely nothing defense against the caprices of political professionals, particularly for marginalized anybody. 11

Leave a Reply